Hi Swathi,

I have reviewed your PR locally and am able to access all the links mentioned. Though in your code i noticed a line "Unable to load the chart at this moment. Please try agian later". Please correct the spelling.

Reviewer: Sayali Sable
Date: January 28, 2026
Branch Tested: Swathi_PR_Review_Team_Analytics_Dashboard

Testing Environment

• Frontend: localhost:5173
• Backend: Development branch (localhost:4500)
• Node.js: v20.19.4

Problem Fixed
Before this PR, the following URLs showed "Page not found" error:

• /pr-dashboard/overview
• /pr-dashboard/promotion-eligibility
• /pr-dashboard/top-reviewed-prs
• /pr-dashboard/details

Solution Implemented
Added 4 new route definitions in src/routes.jsx file:

• Line 903: Route for /pr-dashboard/overview (PRDashboardOverview component)
• Lines 904-908: Route for /pr-dashboard/promotion-eligibility (PRDashboardPromotionEligibility component)
• Lines 909-913: Route for /pr-dashboard/top-reviewed-prs (PRDashboardTopReviewedPRs component)
• Line 914: Route for /pr-dashboard/details (PRDashboardDetails component)

Testing Results
All 4 Routes Working
Tested all 4 URLs and confirmed pages load successfully without "Page not found" error:

1. Overview Page - Loads correctly, displays PR metrics (Open PRs, Stale PRs, Avg Review Time)
2. Promotion Eligibility Page - Loads correctly, displays promotion review table
3. Top Reviewed PRs Page - Loads correctly, displays sorted list of PRs by review activity
4. Details Page - Loads correctly, displays PR details with description and CI/CD status

Multi-Role Testing
Tested with 3 different user roles as required:

• Admin Account: All 4 routes load correctly
• Manager Account: All 4 routes load correctly
• Volunteer Account: All 4 routes load correctly

Code Changes Review

• Only 12 lines added to routes.jsx (+12 lines, 0 deletions)
• Clean implementation using ProtectedRoute wrapper
• Consistent with existing route patterns in the file
• All routes properly mapped to correct components

Findings

• All 4 routes now accessible without "Page not found" error
• Pages load across all user roles
• No console errors
• Routes follow existing code patterns
• Minimal, focused change - only adds necessary routes
• Note: "Failed to load Reviewers" message on promotion-eligibility page is a backend data issue, not related to this routing fix

Conclusion
PR successfully fixes the "Page not found" errors for all 4 PR Dashboard URLs. Routes are properly implemented and work across all user roles. This is a clean, focused fix that addresses the exact problem described.

Hi Swathi,

Thanks for the update. Re-reviewed your PR and i am able to access all the links.

Hi Swathi,

Good job with this fix, working well.

I have re-reviewed the PR to approve it for merge.

Hi Swathi,

Well done with this implementation. URLs work.